Do Children Need Concrete Instantiations to Learn an Abstract Concept?
نویسندگان
چکیده
The effects of relevant concreteness on learning and transfer were investigated. Sixth grade students learned artificial instantiations of a simple mathematical concept. Some students were presented with instantiations that communicated concreteness relevant to the to-be-learned concept, while others learned generic instantiations involving abstract symbols. Results suggest that relevant concreteness may have some advantage over generic for learning. However, relevant concreteness hinders transfer of conceptual knowledge to novel isomorphic situations, while generic instantiations promote transfer.
منابع مشابه
Transfer of Mathematical Knowledge: The Portability of Generic Instantiations
Mathematical concepts are often difficult to acquire. This difficulty is evidenced by failure of knowledge to transfer to novel analogous situations. One approach to this challenge is to present the learner with a concrete instantiation of the to-be-learned concept. Concrete instantiations communicate more information than their abstract, generic counterparts and, in doing so, they may facilita...
متن کامل“Concreteness fading” promotes transfer of mathematical knowledge
Recent studies have suggested that educators should avoid concrete instantiations when the goal is to promote transfer. However, concrete instantiations may benefit transfer in the long run, particularly if they are “faded” into more abstract instantiations. Undergraduates were randomly assigned to learn a mathematical concept in one of three conditions: generic, in which the concept was instan...
متن کاملThe Effects of Learning Multiple Instantiations on Transfer
The effects on transfer of learning multiple instantiations were investigated. Undergraduate college students learned one or more artificial instantiations of a simple mathematical concept. Some students were presented with instantiations that communicated concreteness relevant to the to-be-learned concept, while others learned generic instantiations involving abstract symbols. Learning one or ...
متن کاملEffects of Concreteness on Representation: An Explanation for Differential Transfer
This study investigated the nature of internal representations constructed from learning concrete or generic instantiations of an abstract concept. Undergraduate students learned instantiations of a mathematical group that were generic, communicated concreteness relevant to the concept, or communicated concreteness irrelevant to the concept. Students who learned relevantly concrete instantiatio...
متن کاملChildren's acquisition of fraction knowledge from concrete versus generic instantiations
The goal of this experiment was to investigate elementary school children’s ability to acquire basic fraction knowledge. The degree of concreteness of instantiations of proportions was varied between subjects. First-grade children learned to label proportions of objects with fraction. Proportions were presented either as concrete, colorful flowers or as generic black and white circles. Followin...
متن کامل